Why I Didn’t Leave. Until I Did.
Whenever someone opens up about their experience with an abusive relationship, whether it’s a celebrity divorce in the news or your loved one confiding to you that their marriage has severe issues, you might wonder why they didn’t leave sooner…or why they’re staying.
The answer from the outside seems so obvious: get out! But if you’ve never experienced the complexities of these kinds of relationships, it can be hard to realize that they’ve been on a rollercoaster of fear and confusion, with hope constantly reborn only to have it dashed repeatedly.
My story…
I know what it’s like to be the woman who’s keeping her mouth shut, trying to convince others that all’s going well – when it’s most decidedly not. I also know that after I was hit and I continued the relationship, I blamed myself, and was too easily convinced that I’d made it happen.
It became my fault. My fault for provoking him, my fault for not understanding him better, my fault for keeping the secret, my fault for staying.
I absorbed that guilt like a sponge. I struggled for years to find my worth while being in a relationship that was highly chaotic, dramatic, and critical. I kept trying to gain his trust and respect, which was an unattainable goal, but I kept trying, nonetheless. I kept trying and failing, which only fed my insecurity.
That very failure further proved (irrationally) that I was to blame. The attempt was to grind into me just how imperfect – how less than – I was. It simply seemed as if there was no way out.
My life was not in physical danger like so many women; I don’t want to portray that it was. The far greater part of the damage was emotional. It took deciding I was never going to make it right. Ever. And that it was okay to be imperfect. Even to divorce a second time – which held its own sense of shame.
While this was all over quite a long time ago, you never forget what it feels like to be her. If you’ve never been that person, please understand that it’s not as simple as just walking away.
What are trauma bonds?
Years later, I came to understand this dynamic is called a trauma bond.
This is when the cycle of abuse is repeated so many times that the patterns of shame, confusion, hope, uncertainty, and guilt feed on and reinforce one another. Usually there’s a power imbalance in a trauma bond, with the abuser wielding rewards and punishments that keep the abused feeling that the situation is unpredictable and out of their control yet, paradoxically, their fault. Any self-worth becomes increasingly difficult as the cycle continues which, in turn, makes leaving the relationship seem about as possible as deciding to spontaneously levitate.
It’s also a frequent part of trying to be in a relationship with someone with narcissistic traits.
But it’s not impossible; it takes some work and isn’t easy to do on your own, but you can walk away. Reach out to others, seek professional help if needed and possible, and know that nobody deserves ridicule, contempt, or disdain. Physical or sexual violence should never be used to control or subdue.
And that no matter what… it is not your fault.
You can hear more about mental health and many other topics by listening to my podcast, SelfWork with Dr. Margaret Rutherford. Subscribe to my website and receive one weekly newsletter including my weekly blog post and podcast! If you’d like to join my FaceBook closed group, then click here and answer the membership questions! Welcome!
My new book entitled Perfectly Hidden Depression has arrived and you can order here! Its message is specifically for those with a struggle with strong perfectionism which acts to mask underlying emotional pain. But the many self-help techniques described can be used by everyone who chooses to begin to address emotions long hidden away that are clouding and sabotaging your current life.
And there’s a new way to send me a message! You can record by clicking below and ask your question or make a comment. You’ll have 90 seconds to do so and that time goes quickly. By recording, you’re giving SelfWork (and me) permission to use your voice on the podcast. I’ll look forward to hearing from you!
Photo by Tobi.
Originally published on September 14, 2014; updated and republished on October 2, 2022.
If some women are inspired to leave by the discussion, it’s so worth it. But I think we do have an overactive, 24-hour news media and they have to fill their newshole with all this repetitive stuff. Ithink it does lose its impact over time with talking heads beating it to death over and over. The discussion is important but the repetition is counter-productive.
Carol I think it takes a lot more than television discussions over a weekend for a woman to decide to leave. We do this for everything from Robin Williams suicide to someone being diagnosed with a disease or mental illness. Suddenly it’s the news of the moment. And we go on. Sadly. The very chronicity of the problem is the problem. It goes on and on. It wears on the victim. Thank you for commenting and I understand that vast amounts of sudden attention are too much. Perhaps it’s better than nothing.
Thank you for sharing your personal experience. No one is immune to the several forms of abuse that we can experience and continuing to share is absolutely vital for those who are currently in the situation.
When I was in the situation, I had lost my voice and my self worth had dissolved through needing the approval (never coming) of someone I had made ultimately important in my life. Once I was completely emotionally defeated, the simplest moves to regain myself took incredible effort and also the constant reminders of my support group of professional and personal friends. Death seemed better than Life.
Rebuilding myself took creating my own voice in my mind and years of ups and downs as I learned who I was and am. Nine years later, my mind is at peace, I am no longer a victim and I know the red flags to watch for. There is no room for toxic people in my life and happily, they are no longer attracted to me.
Thank you for your story Izzie. I certainly hope that others can have the same or similar outcome. It can be done.
If some women are inspired to leave by the discussion, it’s so worth it. But I think we do have an overactive, 24-hour news media and they have to fill their newshole with all this repetitive stuff. Ithink it does lose its impact over time with talking heads beating it to death over and over. The discussion is important but the repetition is counter-productive.
An important discussion, indeed. Thank you for your post.
Thank you Mindy. I hope so.
Thank you for sharing your personal experience. No one is immune to the several forms of abuse that we can experience and continuing to share is absolutely vital for those who are currently in the situation.
When I was in the situation, I had lost my voice and my self worth had dissolved through needing the approval (never coming) of someone I had made ultimately important in my life. Once I was completely emotionally defeated, the simplest moves to regain myself took incredible effort and also the constant reminders of my support group of professional and personal friends. Death seemed better than Life.
Rebuilding myself took creating my own voice in my mind and years of ups and downs as I learned who I was and am. Nine years later, my mind is at peace, I am no longer a victim and I know the red flags to watch for. There is no room for toxic people in my life and happily, they are no longer attracted to me.
“Why are we still talking about this? Is this really newsworthy?”
You nailed it. We will not stop talking about it until it stops. Forever. As always, thank you for being vulnerable and sharing your story.
Well said. Thanks.
You are welcome. Thanks for commenting